Tirupur Dye Houses closed

Tirupur in India is one of the world’s centres for clothing production. Sitting next to the city of Coimbatore, Tirupur is a place I have visited on a number of occasions, to visit factories, print shops, dye houses and so on.

Principally Tirupur is home to knit wear factories, they make tee-shirts and other knitted cotton items, many of which find their way to high street chains here in the UK.You may be wearing something right now that was made in Tirupur.

Certainly if you buy from shops like supermarkets or the larger chain stores, then there is a very good chance you have items which were made in Tirupur. But as well as being home to a few high standard production units, Tirupur has also struggled in recent years, with a reputation for production facilities which are not what they could be – or should be. Where workers are, if not necessarily mistreated (although sometimes that is the case), then not given the respect or conditions that they deserve. This is not a malice thing, it is about costs. If you are looking at saving a few cents on each garment, then you arent going to spend as much on your workforce, or their workplace.

Hand in hand with this kind of treatment of humans, has gone harsh treatment of the environment. One of the most environmentally damaging aspects of the clothing supply chain is the dye process – because of the scale of production, the dye plants are huge things, with massive amounts of chemicals used on a daily basis. The usual process for the kind of fabric which teeshirts are made of, is Jet dyeing, where fabric is zoomed through a process where jets of hot water containing dye and other chemicals are pumped into them – this process uses large amounts of electricity, steam and of course the chemicals themselves.

The problem comes of course, not so much in the dyeing process itself, which is energy intensive but contained,  but in the disposal of effluent.  There has to be an issue of effluent after the dying process, and it will necessarily contain, among other nasties, large quantities of salt – as anyone who has dyed a piece of fabric at home will know.

The cheapest way of getting rid of such effluent is to dump it in a water course, and that is what most operators do, they simply pump their polluting effluent into nearby rivers. This kind of pollution has meant that the agricultural land in the area has been badly affected by pollution and salination over a number of years.

Attempts have been made to set this right, plants have been prosecuted and closed down, even the British government got involved (they realised we import 90%+ of our clothes, and recognised we have some responsibility to the producers) and for a while Tirupur began to be held up as an example of ‘best practise’. Levels were set to regulate the amount of salt in effluent, to try and protect the surrounding farmland, and it all seemed to be going in the right direction.

Not for long of course.

This week comes the news that Madras high court has ordered over 700 dye plants to be shut down – yes, 700. The local electricity board has begun to shut off power to those who have failed to comply with the order. The reason is that the level of salt in the effluent discharged into the local water courses is too high. Once again farmland has been terribly damaged by discharge of salt – and its the dye houses which are to blame.

As it stands the 700 plants are on shut down, thousands of jobs which go with that are at risk or already lost – suppliers will not be getting their materials, clothing supply will be affected. Farmland is polluted and will not produce a proper harvest this year, and meanwhile people continue to buy cheap clothes because they dont see the link.

I actually feel rather sorry for the dye house owners and operators, they are in a hard world, trying to provide a service against very tight price demands – I genuinely feel that we, the consumers and producers are not really being fair on them.

I feel that at the centre of it all, it’s our consumption that is driving this pollution problem, it’s our quest for a bargain that is putting lives and livelihoods at risk, and it’s our choices which have meant that today many poor people stand on the brink of ruin.

So yes, 700 dye houses are closed today, and I’m sorry to have to tell you that it is pretty much our fault.


6 thoughts on “Tirupur Dye Houses closed

  1. Hard isn’t it? In one way, we/you need to offer these people other solutions rather than just pulling away the work on which they depend. On the other hand, all of our solutions appear to involve international trade, which I can’t really justify either. So the catch-22 is that you don’t want them to continue doing this dirty work, but you also can’t offer them many alternatives.

  2. This is beyond tragic and no doubt will cost lives as well as communities and has always done so. I suspect dyers, like tanners and weavers, are mostly Dalits and will not find much political sympathy in India.

    But I don’t think we have a moral dilemma as westerners. Rather, we have an immoral system. That’s not to pass-the-buck but rather to say that we would be more use finding new ways to live than putting on horse-hair shirts.

    Um. Unless, of course – in this example – we need to put on horse-hair shirts. Hum.

  3. Not sure how feeling bad helps either; unless it leads to us trying to change the system.

    I appreciate that I’m preaching to the choir here.

    I’m responding to “it’s our choices which have meant that today many poor people stand on the brink of ruin” by suggesting that if we can’t find morally good choices that’s not because morality is found wanting but the system that sets up a hobson’s choice.

    My bishop was writing recently about moral dilemmas in relation to consumering and needing to find a way to act morally. I’d suggest if we can’t act morally with the system we need a different system.

    “If there are no rules, there is no game” Francois Lyotard.

  4. Keith, I have been thinking about this for a few days – in some ways it feels like I have been thinking about this for my entire life.

    It seems to me that we need a systematic change and it strikes me that the system we have is almost inevitably unstable and will eventually fall. No system based on injustice can prevail indefinitely.

    The struggle is knowing how to live in the here-and-now. The most convincing argument I heard some years ago from Alastair McIntosh, who told me that moral people had to train themselves to become global hospice workers. The struggle for me is not in reinventing ways to bring down the empire or to speak truth to those in Power. It seems to me that we’re far beyond that having any useful purpose.

    We cannot even honestly change ourselves. We have no moral choices. Our lives are just immoral, end of story.

    It seems to me the best we can do is try to best use the unearned resources we have to train ourselves for an uncertain future where everything we see will be stripped away.

  5. hey keith…
    livelihood has nothing to do with dalits….tirupur is a place where the dravidian movement has had its dominance…the movement is infact against the caste system…the workers are of course from the economically backward class…this has nothing to do with the caste system..some people are poor, while some are rich…thts everywhere- even in europe and america…..but i appreciate that you are not blaming anyone for it…rightly said we all are dwelling in an immoral system…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s